# Whining, Not Listening, Lying and 'I Hate You': What Your Child Means

> Whining, not listening, lying and 'I hate you', read as signals, from Dr. Becky Kennedy.

Stage: toddler - Topic: Behavior - Page: https://www.askcladle.com/guides/toddler/kennedy-whining-lying-and-rudeness

Grounded in: Dr. Becky Kennedy's *Good Inside*, whose second half takes common hard behaviors one chapter at a time, and her Good Inside podcast. Summarized in Cradle's own words, not quoted; read the book for her full explanation.

Reviewed: 2026-11

## TLDR

- Whining, not listening, lying and "I hate you" usually come from feeling disconnected, powerless or overwhelmed.
- Connect before instructions, make telling the truth feel safe, and respond to the feeling behind harsh words.
- Stay sturdy without matching the intensity. Escalating or dangerous behavior is worth a pediatrician visit.

## The approach across all of them

Ask what the behavior is telling you before deciding how to respond. Most of these behaviors come
from a child who feels disconnected, powerless or overwhelmed, not from a bad child.

## Whining

A whine often means "I don't feel I can manage this alone." Rather than "Use your big voice!" in an
irritated tone, look for the need underneath: hunger, tiredness, wanting your attention. A bit of
connection or playfulness ("Hmm, the whiny voice snuck in. Let's find your strong voice") usually
works better than scolding.

## Not listening

Children are more willing to cooperate with someone they feel connected to. Get close, get on their
level, say their name and connect with what they are doing before giving the instruction. Make it
playful when you can. Fewer, clearer requests beat many repeated ones.

## Lying

Young children often lie when the truth feels unsafe, or because they wish something weren't true.
Instead of interrogating or trapping them, make telling the truth feel safe: respond to the wish
("I bet you wish that cup hadn't broken"), deal calmly with the problem, and say you'd rather know
the truth even when it's hard.

## "I hate you" and rude words

Treat harsh words as a sign of a feeling too big for the child's skills, not a statement of fact.
Respond to the feeling ("You're so angry I said no"), stay sturdy, and avoid matching the
intensity. Talk later, when calm, about kinder ways to show anger.

## When to check in

If behavior is escalating, dangerous, or comes with persistent sadness, fear or big changes in
sleep, eating or school, talk to the pediatrician or a child therapist.